Lilly S Bontrager, MD

Primary Care, Family Medicine, Preventive Medicine, Women's Health

4.9 out of 5

Virtual Visits Available

To schedule an Appointment call or visit mercy.com

Book Online 419-692-5611

Meet Lilly

Board certified in Family Medicine, I provide comprehensive care to patients of all ages, with special interests in women’s health and culinary medicine. I value the relationship with patients by listening and engaging them towards their personal health goals. I am happy to provide care for both English-speaking and Spanish-speaking patients. In my spare time, I enjoy spending time with my family and pursuing musical interests.

Overview

Gender: Female
Languages: English

Spanish
Age Groups Seen: Pediatrics

Teenagers

Adults

Geriatrics
Hospital Affiliations: Mercy Health - St. Rita's Medical Center
Networks

Experience

Provider Education

Fort Wayne Medical Education Program Residency, Family Medicine, 2007

Indiana University School Of Medicine Medical School, 2004

Certifications

American Board of Family Medicine (Family Medicine) Board Certification

Find Locations Near You

Insurances Accepted

Information is subject to change without notice. Please contact your insurance provider for confirmation.

Aetna Better Health OH
Aetna Commercial & Aetna Medicare OH
Aetna Medicare Advantage ACO OH
Align Senior Care OH
AmeriHealth Caritas Medicaid OH
Anthem Elevance Health KY & OH
Buckeye Health Plan OH
CareSource OH
Cigna OH
CIN-MHS MSSP
CommuniCare Medicare Advantage OH
Devoted Health Medicare Advantage OH
Frontpath Health Coalition OH
HealthSmart OH
Humana Medicare Advantage ACO OH
Humana Military KY & OH
Humana OH
Lutheran Preferred OH
Medicaid OH
Medical Mutual of Ohio
Medicare OH
Medicare Railroad KY & OH
Medigold OH
Molina Medicare & Medicaid OH
Multiplan OH
Ohio Health Choice
Paramount Elite Medicare Advantage OH
Parkview-Signature One OH
Payer Provider
Quality Care Partners PPO OH
Sedgwick/Careworks KY OH SC VA
SummaCare OH
The Health Plan OH
United Healthcare OH
United Medicare Advantage ACO OH
Valor Health Plan OH
Wellcare Meridian MI

Ratings & Reviews

We believe in your choice to find the best care possible. With that in mind, it’s important to us that you have all the information you need readily available when considering making an appointment. We think it’s key that you understand how the Patient Satisfaction Rating works. Learn more about our survey process.

Overall Score

4.9 out of 5 217 ratings, 27 reviews

Patient Reviews

1 2 3 4 >
	March 2025 Dr Bontrager is very understanding and takes time with you. I don't feel she is rushing you through.
	March 2025 Dr Lily is amazing! Just love her. She never makes me feel rushed and she listens to all my concerns and answers all my questions completely. And most of all you can tell that she really cares.
	March 2025 Dr Lilly is super if she could train more good dr like her and keep in our area would make Mercy medical the best in Ohio
	March 2025 Good
	February 2025 Dr. Bontrager and staff are the Best!
	February 2025 Dr Bontrager is easy to talk to about any concerns. She takes time to listen and talk to you. She is an excellent doctor
	February 2025 Dr. Bontrager always listens to my concerns and tries to help me come to the best solution for ME, not just a generalized answer. She truly cares!
	January 2025 Excellent service!