Mercy Health Provider

Lilly S Bontrager, MD

Primary Care, Family Medicine, Preventive Medicine, Women's Health

4.8 out of 5

Accepting New Patients

Virtual Visits Available

Meet Lilly

Board certified in Family Medicine, I provide comprehensive care to patients of all ages, with special interests in women’s health and culinary medicine. I value the relationship with patients by listening and engaging them towards their personal health goals. I am happy to provide care for both English-speaking and Spanish-speaking patients. In my spare time, I enjoy spending time with my family and pursuing musical interests.

Find Locations Near You

Insurances Accepted

Information is subject to change without notice. Please contact your insurance provider for confirmation.

  • Aetna
  • Anthem BlueCross Blue Shield Ohio
  • Buckeye Health Plan (Medicaid Ohio)
  • CareSource
  • Cigna
  • Communicare Advantage
  • Devoted Health
  • Frontpath
  • HealthSmart
  • Lutheran Preferred
  • Medicaid Ohio
  • Medical Mutual of Ohio
  • Medicare Ohio
  • Medicare Railroad
  • Medigold
  • Mercy Health Select, LLC
  • Meridian Health Plan of Michigan
  • Multiplan, Inc.
  • Ohio Health Choice
  • Ohio PPO Connect
  • Paramount
  • Parkview – Signature Care
  • Quality Care Partners
  • SummaCare Health Plan
  • The Health Plan
  • United Healthcare
  • Valor Health Plan
  • WellCare of Kentucky

Ratings & Reviews

We believe in your choice to find the best care possible. With that in mind, it’s important to us that you have all the information you need readily available when considering making an appointment. We think it’s key that you understand how the Patient Satisfaction Rating works. Learn more about our survey process.

Overall Score

4.8 out of 5 177 ratings, 22 reviews

Patient Reviews

1 2 3 >
March 2022
Very positive person
March 2022
Dr. Lilly was very caring and thorough. This was the first time that I had met her and she explained things very well and I was extremely pleased with her.
February 2022
I was very happy with my visit with Dr Bontrager. She is a caring and knowledgeable physician.
February 2022
Both the assistants and Dr Bontrager herself are attentive and engaging providers. They are positive and caring as well as efficient and professional. I would recommend this practice without hesitation to others.
February 2022
Dr. Bontrager was great. She took the time to listen to my concerns, explain options, and let me make my own decisions as to treatment based on her explanations.
January 2022
She took a lot of time with me and listened and made me feel very comfortable. She did a great job
January 2022
I would reommend dr. Bontreger to anyone. She is one of the few that cares anymore
December 2021
Always Awesome!!