Sara A Nicholas, DO | Obstetrics and Gynecology | Mercy Health - Youngstown Women's Center
Mercy Health Provider

Sara A Nicholas, DO

Obstetrics and Gynecology

Meet Sara

Dr. Nicholas is board certified in obstetrics and gynecology. She is a Northeast Ohio native and has been serving the community since 2015. She has a special interest in minimally invasive surgery. When she is not working, she enjoys spending time with her husband and two little girls.

Find Locations Near You

Insurances Accepted

Information is subject to change without notice. Please contact your insurance provider for confirmation.

  • Aetna Better Health OH
  • Aetna Commercial & Aetna Medicare OH
  • Align Senior Care OH
  • AmeriHealth Caritas Medicaid OH
  • Anthem Elevance Health KY & OH
  • AultCare OH
  • Buckeye Health Plan OH
  • CareSource OH
  • Cigna OH
  • CIN-MHS NON-MSSP
  • CommuniCare Medicare Advantage OH
  • Devoted Health Medicare Advantage OH KY
  • DOL KY & OH
  • HealthSmart OH
  • Healthspring Medicare Advantage OH
  • Humana Military KY & OH
  • Humana OH
  • Immergrun OH
  • Martin's Point Health Care OH
  • Medicaid OH
  • Medical Mutual of Ohio
  • Medicare OH
  • Medicare Railroad KY & OH
  • Molina Medicare & Medicaid OH
  • Multiplan OH
  • NaphCare OH
  • Ohio BWC
  • Ohio Health Choice
  • Paramount Elite Medicare Advantage OH
  • Payer Provider
  • Perennial Medicare Advantage OH
  • Quality Care Partners PPO OH
  • Sedgwick/Careworks KY OH SC VA
  • SummaCare OH
  • The Health Plan OH
  • United Healthcare OH
  • Valor Health Plan OH
  • Wellcare Meridian MI

Ratings & Reviews

We believe in your choice to find the best care possible. With that in mind, it’s important to us that you have all the information you need readily available when considering making an appointment. We think it’s key that you understand how the Patient Satisfaction Rating works. Learn more about our survey process.

Overall Score

4.8 out of 5 138 ratings, 21 reviews

Patient Reviews

1 2 3 >
December 2025
She was so nice and made me feel very comfortable. I would definitely recommend her to friends and family.
December 2025
The doctor explains in detail about my condition.
December 2025
Dr. Sara Nicholas was so thorough with me and listened to all my concerns. She is wonderful to her patients and truly listens to them. She is the best.
December 2025
This was my first time to see Dr. Nicholas, and I found her to be extremely personable, compassionate, patient and professional.
November 2025
I have already recommended this office to a friend that is looking to switch providers.
November 2025
Dr. Nicholas was very kind.
September 2025
I have not been to the GYN for 25 years because of a horrific experience with the Dr. I was VERY NERVOUS about this appointment. The nurse and doctor were VERY CARING. They wanted me to have a good ex...Show more
September 2025
Dr Sara Nicholas went through all options before choosing the best one. I felt very good and comfortable with her, knowing that she really knew my chart well. Very important!