Timothy P O'Donnell, MD

General Surgery, Colon and Rectal Surgery

Accepting New Patients

Meet Timothy

I am a Cleveland native, board certified in Colon and Rectal Surgery and General Surgery. Like everything in medicine, trust is earned. I hope to provide care that exceeds your expectations. I believe I have the knowledge and expertise to meet your needs. I enjoy drone flying, traveling and Cleveland sports.

Find Locations Near You

Insurances Accepted

Information is subject to change without notice. Please contact your insurance provider for confirmation.

  • Aetna Better Health OH
  • Aetna Commercial & Aetna Medicare OH
  • AmeriHealth Caritas Medicaid OH
  • Anthem Elevance Health KY & OH
  • Buckeye Health Plan OH
  • CareSource OH
  • Cigna OH
  • CIN - MHS NON-MSSP
  • CommuniCare Medicare Advantage OH
  • Devoted Health Medicare Advantage OH KY
  • Frontpath Health Coalition OH
  • HealthSmart OH
  • Healthspring Medicare Advantage OH
  • Humana Military KY & OH
  • Humana OH
  • Martin's Point Health Care OH
  • Medicaid OH
  • Medical Mutual of Ohio
  • Medicare OH
  • Molina Medicare & Medicaid OH
  • Multiplan OH
  • Ohio BWC
  • Ohio Health Choice
  • OMC (Oscar Mgmt) OH KY SC VA
  • Paramount Elite Medicare Advantage OH
  • Payer Provider
  • Perennial Medicare Advantage OH
  • Quality Care Partners PPO OH
  • Sedgwick/Careworks KY OH SC VA
  • SummaCare OH
  • The Health Plan OH
  • United Healthcare OH
  • Valor Health Plan OH
  • Wellcare Meridian MI

Ratings & Reviews

We believe in your choice to find the best care possible. With that in mind, it’s important to us that you have all the information you need readily available when considering making an appointment. We think it’s key that you understand how the Patient Satisfaction Rating works. Learn more about our survey process.

Overall Score

4.7 out of 5 139 ratings, 16 reviews

Patient Reviews

1 2 >
February 2026
Good
February 2026
Very good
February 2026
Dr. O'Donnell is very caring and professional. He has a way of putting you at ease during the appointment
January 2026
Friendly and professional
January 2026
Dr. O'Donnell remembered me & my nervousness from previous appointments, and put me at ease
January 2026
Dr. O'Donnell is a very professional and caring person. I feel very lucky to have him as my surgeon.
December 2025
Excellent doctor with great attitude!!
November 2025
This was my second visit and it's not a comfortable reason for being there but he has made my visits as comfortable as could be, if I have any more issues I would definitely go back to him.
Loading